Skip to content

Types of Psychological mirroring

What are there various types of mirroring? How do they differ and what are the main papers. For example: childhood mirroring vs psychopathic mirroring.

Phenomenon Timing What's Copied Mechanism Purpose/Function When It Feels "Off"
Childhood Mirroring (Meltzoff & Moore, 1977) Infancy onwards Facial expressions, vocalisations, movements Innate developmental process; active intermodal mapping (AIM) Learning, bonding, developing empathy and sense of self N/A - normal development
Mirror Neurons (di Pellegrino et al., 1992; Rizzolatti et al., 1996) Milliseconds Motor actions, possibly emotions Neurological - neurons fire both when performing and observing actions Underpins imitation, empathy, action understanding N/A - neurological substrate
Chameleon Effect (Chartrand & Bargh, 1999) 2-5 seconds Postures, gestures, mannerisms, facial expressions Automatic, nonconscious perception-behaviour link Social glue; increases liking and rapport unconsciously Too fast (<2 sec), too precise, or too frequent - triggers suspicion
Communication Accommodation Theory (Giles et al., 1973) Minutes to ongoing Vocabulary, phrases, accent, speech rate, tone Can be conscious or unconscious Signalling affiliation, reducing social distance, seeking approval When motive appears manipulative or self-serving
Mimicry-Deception Theory (Jones, 2014) Variable - short or long-term Emotions, cooperative behaviours, trustworthy signals Deliberate, strategic - used to avoid detection Exploitation, resource extraction, appearing trustworthy while deceiving Short-term: rushed charm, quick exit. Long-term: mask slips under stress, history doesn't match
Affective Mimicry in Psychopathy (Book et al., 2015) Deliberate/on-demand Fearful expressions, remorse, prosocial emotions Cognitive understanding of emotion intact; emotional experience absent "Mask of sanity" - appear genuine to exploit others Cleckley's "emotional poverty" - the affect is technically correct but hollow