Types of Psychological mirroring
What are there various types of mirroring? How do they differ and what are the main papers. For example: childhood mirroring vs psychopathic mirroring.
| Phenomenon | Timing | What's Copied | Mechanism | Purpose/Function | When It Feels "Off" |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Childhood Mirroring (Meltzoff & Moore, 1977) | Infancy onwards | Facial expressions, vocalisations, movements | Innate developmental process; active intermodal mapping (AIM) | Learning, bonding, developing empathy and sense of self | N/A - normal development |
| Mirror Neurons (di Pellegrino et al., 1992; Rizzolatti et al., 1996) | Milliseconds | Motor actions, possibly emotions | Neurological - neurons fire both when performing and observing actions | Underpins imitation, empathy, action understanding | N/A - neurological substrate |
| Chameleon Effect (Chartrand & Bargh, 1999) | 2-5 seconds | Postures, gestures, mannerisms, facial expressions | Automatic, nonconscious perception-behaviour link | Social glue; increases liking and rapport unconsciously | Too fast (<2 sec), too precise, or too frequent - triggers suspicion |
| Communication Accommodation Theory (Giles et al., 1973) | Minutes to ongoing | Vocabulary, phrases, accent, speech rate, tone | Can be conscious or unconscious | Signalling affiliation, reducing social distance, seeking approval | When motive appears manipulative or self-serving |
| Mimicry-Deception Theory (Jones, 2014) | Variable - short or long-term | Emotions, cooperative behaviours, trustworthy signals | Deliberate, strategic - used to avoid detection | Exploitation, resource extraction, appearing trustworthy while deceiving | Short-term: rushed charm, quick exit. Long-term: mask slips under stress, history doesn't match |
| Affective Mimicry in Psychopathy (Book et al., 2015) | Deliberate/on-demand | Fearful expressions, remorse, prosocial emotions | Cognitive understanding of emotion intact; emotional experience absent | "Mask of sanity" - appear genuine to exploit others | Cleckley's "emotional poverty" - the affect is technically correct but hollow |