Skip to content

Noteable Narcissism authors in Psychology

Generated by ChatGPT4o (e.g. What were Herbert Rosenfeld's theories on narcissism)

This article has a very good history of authors who focused on Narcissism and NPD - Narcissism: From Kohut to CAT (1997)

1. Herbert Rosenfeld

Author Summary

Herbert Rosenfeld (1909–1986) was a British psychoanalyst known for his work within Kleinian object relations theory, particularly his contributions to understanding severe personality disorders, including narcissism and psychosis. Rosenfeld emphasized how splitting, projective identification, and the internalized "bad object" shape the internal world of individuals with pathological narcissism. He distinguished between benign narcissism, which preserves some capacity for reality testing, and malignant narcissism, characterized by destructive omnipotence and devaluation of others. His clinical work highlighted the difficulty of treating patients with entrenched narcissistic defenses and the need to carefully interpret their defensive use of grandiosity and aggression.

Theories on Narcissism

  • Narcissism as a Defense: Narcissism protects against feelings of vulnerability and psychic fragmentation through mechanisms like splitting and omnipotence.
  • Benign vs. Malignant Narcissism: Benign narcissism is less destructive and retains some reality testing, while malignant narcissism involves self-idealization, hostility to dependency, and aggression.
  • Splitting and Projective Identification: Narcissists split the self and others into "good" and "bad" parts, projecting unwanted aspects outward.
  • Narcissistic Internal World: Pathological narcissism involves an internalized grandiose self that devalues external reality and relationships.
  • Therapeutic Resistance: Narcissistic patients often resist therapy due to their rigid defenses, requiring careful interpretation of their dynamics.

2. Otto Kernberg

Author Summary

Otto Kernberg (b. 1928) is a psychoanalyst and psychiatrist who advanced the understanding of personality disorders, especially borderline and narcissistic personality disorders, within object relations theory. Kernberg emphasized the role of splitting and primitive defenses in narcissistic pathology, where grandiosity acts as a shield against feelings of inadequacy and dependency. He developed the concept of malignant narcissism, a severe and destructive form blending narcissism, antisocial tendencies, and aggression. His treatment approach focuses on interpreting the defenses of narcissistic patients, helping them integrate fragmented self-images to achieve more stable interpersonal functioning.

Theories on Narcissism

  • Narcissism as a Continuum: Ranges from normal, healthy narcissism to pathological forms that involve dependency on external validation.
  • Narcissistic Personality Organization: Characterized by grandiosity, lack of empathy, and fragile self-esteem masked by exploitative behavior.
  • Development of Pathological Narcissism: Arises from early failures in caregiving, unresolved aggression, and an inability to integrate positive and negative self-images.
  • Splitting and Defensive Mechanisms: Includes splitting, idealization, and devaluation to protect against feelings of inadequacy.
  • Malignant Narcissism: A severe form involving grandiosity, antisocial behavior, sadism, and paranoia.
  • Therapy Challenges: Patients often resist therapy, requiring the therapist to carefully address transference dynamics and confront grandiosity.

3. Heinz Kohut

Author Summary

Heinz Kohut (1913–1981) was a psychoanalyst and the founder of self psychology, a theory that focuses on the development of the self and the role of empathy in human relationships. Kohut viewed narcissism as a developmental issue arising from unmet needs for mirroring, idealization, and twinship in early childhood. He distinguished between healthy and pathological narcissism, arguing that the latter stems from failures in the caregiving environment that disrupt the formation of a cohesive self. Kohut's empathetic therapeutic approach emphasizes meeting the patient’s unmet developmental needs to rebuild a cohesive self and foster healthy narcissism. His work revolutionized the treatment of narcissistic disorders by introducing a compassionate and developmental framework.

Theories on Narcissism

  • Development of the Self: Healthy self-esteem arises when caregivers meet a child’s needs for validation (mirroring) and strength (idealization).
  • The Narcissistic Self: Pathological narcissism stems from failures in these needs, leading to a fragmented or grandiose self.
  • Selfobject Needs: Kohut identified mirroring, idealization, and twinship as critical needs in childhood. Unmet needs result in compensatory grandiosity or feelings of isolation.
  • Therapy and Empathy: Empathy is central to treating narcissistic patients, addressing their unmet developmental needs and helping them build a cohesive self.
  • Healthy vs. Pathological Narcissism: Healthy narcissism supports confidence and ambition, while pathological narcissism relies on external validation and masks deep insecurities.
  • Narcissistic Rage: Kohut described rage as a response to threats to the grandiose self, which can manifest as outward aggression or inward shame.

4. Comparison of Theories

Shared Themes:

  • All three theorists recognize grandiosity and defensiveness as central features of pathological narcissism, though they attribute these traits to different developmental or intrapsychic processes.
  • Each highlights the challenges of psychotherapy with narcissistic patients due to their reliance on rigid defenses and difficulty with vulnerability.

Differences:

  • Rosenfeld: Focused on the aggressive and destructive nature of malignant narcissism within Kleinian object relations theory, emphasizing splitting and the internalized "bad object."
  • Kernberg: Highlighted the continuum of narcissism and its relationship to personality structure, emphasizing the integration of fragmented self-images and the concept of malignant narcissism as a severe pathology.
  • Kohut: Provided a developmental framework through self psychology, focusing on unmet needs for mirroring, idealization, and twinship, and offering an empathetic, reparative approach to therapy.

Key Therapeutic Focus:

  • Rosenfeld: Interpretation of aggressive and defensive dynamics.
  • Kernberg: Confrontation of splitting and integration of fragmented selves.
  • Kohut: Empathy and addressing unmet developmental needs to rebuild a cohesive self.